VTMHCA News

Spring 2007

 

A Note from the President:

The evidence continues to pile up that our profession is in a crisis. The following appeared online this May in Psychiatryonline.org, the American Psychiatric Association's online journal:

“"It is difficult to overstate the magnitude of the workforce crisis in behavioral health. ... [T]here is substantial and alarming evidence that the current workforce lacks adequate support to function effectively and is largely unable to deliver care of proven effectiveness in partnership with the people who need services. There is equally compelling evidence of an anemic pipeline of new recruits to meet the complex behavioral health needs of the growing and increasingly diverse population in this country. ... Urgent attention to this crisis is essential."

So begins a report documenting the results of a multiyear process to assess problems in the U.S. behavioral health workforce and develop a shared agenda for improving it. Because neither states nor associations routinely collect information by use of a standardized data set, the report's authors were challenged to assemble a unified picture of the workforce.

The best available estimates indicate that there were slightly more than a half million clinically trained and active mental health professionals in 2002. Psychiatry has remained static in terms of growth, psychology has doubled in size over the past 25 years, and social work has increased by 20% in the past 15 years. Increases in the number of psychiatric nurses with graduate-level preparation largely have been offset by nurses leaving the active workforce and by sharp reductions in the number of graduate nursing students.

The report notes a critical lack of diversity. Most professionals are non-Hispanic whites, often exceeding 90% of discipline composition. For most disciplines, substantially more than half of professionals are over the age of 50, raising serious concerns about whether the pipeline of young professionals will be adequate.

Compounding these concerns are problems with geographic distribution. More than 85% of the 1,669 federally designated mental health shortage areas are rural. Half of U.S. counties do not have a single mental health professional.

In addition to professionals are 145,000 workforce members who have a bachelor's degree or less. This group too seldom receives systematic training and support, the report notes, even though it accounts for up to 40% of the workforce in many public-sector service settings.

The workforce that is specifically trained to provide substance abuse services is small in comparison to the identified need. An estimated 67,000 licensed and unlicensed counselors provide substance abuse treatment and related services. An additional 40,000 professionals are licensed or credentialed to provide such care. The substance abuse workforce is primarily female, older, and white. From 70% to 90% of treatment personnel are Caucasian, and 70% of new counselors are female. The average age of staff is mid-40s to early 50s. Thus staff frequently differ from their predominantly young, male, and minority clientele.

The report also examines system-level factors that strongly influence whether behavioral health needs are met. Throughout the multiyear planning process participants repeatedly expressed concerns that the health care environment is "toxic" to adults in recovery, to youths, and to their families. Workforce members described their low morale and low levels of commitment because of low pay, the absence of career ladders, excessive workloads, tenuous job security, a lack of supervision, and an inability to influence their organization or system.

To address workforce issues, agencies tend to do what is affordable rather than what is effective, according to the report. The most glaring example is the provision of single-session, didactic in-service trainings, despite clear evidence of their ineffectiveness in changing practices.

To address the workforce crisis, the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA) commissioned the Annapolis Coalition on the Behavioral Health Workforce to develop a national action plan. The Coalition is a not-for-profit organization focused on improving workforce development. Since 2000 it has functioned as a neutral convener of individuals, groups, and organizations that recruit, train, employ, license, and receive services from the workforce. The report is the result of an iterative process to which more than 5,000 individuals contributed. The draft report was vetted through a national conference held by SAMHSA in July 2006 with more than 200 participants from all sectors.

The planning process identified seven core, cross-cutting goals and objectives…. For each goal, several objectives and numerous specific action steps are detailed in a 37-page appendix. For example, an objective for goal 4 is to launch a national initiative to ensure that every member of the workforce develops basic competencies in assessment and treatment of substance use disorders and co-occurring disorders. The first action step is to incorporate these competencies into all competency models, preservice and continuing education curricula, accreditation standards, and certification and licensure requirements. The report calls for the creation of a special commission to identify barriers, create strategies to overcome them, and report annually on progress and outcomes.”

I actually took the time to find out if the report addresses the Elephant in the Living Room, i.e. the erosion of incomes in our field. It does, but sort of dances around the question of what to do about it: Goal #3 addresses recruitment and retention of workforce, and notes that a big reason for the crisis is the decline of compensation in the field. However, it notes that compensation is a complex issue and recommends that government and community groups consult with the State Departments of Labor to determine what a “liveable wage” is. Wow.

I think it's much simpler (and harder) than that. What needs to happen is that the entire profession, from the lowest-paid Health Care Aide to the Psychiatrists and Doctoral Level Psychologists and everyone in between, need to join together in an effort to change the status quo. This will entail effort and cost. We need to start thinking in terms of "How much time and money am I personally willing to invest to work towards the goal of a healthy, thriving mental health/substance abuse profession?" For example, to bring it closer to home, "What is needed to form a permanent lobbying force here in Vermont that would represent our issues adequately?"

The SAMSA report can be found here.

Don Rhoades, MA, LCMHC, LADC
VTMHCA President